feat(studio): integrate memcard persistence and headless controls
Test / Tests and coverage
Intrepid/Prometeu/Studio/pipeline/pr-master This commit looks good

Persist cartridge identity and slot configuration, add MemcardBoot and the MemcardBuffer SDK, and consume the runtime's negotiated memcard host controls with protected teardown.

Qualify save/reopen and version upgrades through distinct configured runtime processes. Include specs, examples, regression evidence and the consolidated discussion lesson.
This commit is contained in:
2026-10-30 11:01:02 +00:00
parent 3a3417eb44
commit 1d8b8c2101
110 changed files with 6502 additions and 85 deletions
@@ -206,9 +206,16 @@ See [Concrete generic structs and free functions](17.%20Generic%20Structs%20and%
## Guest hook marker identity
LifecycleMarker explicitly distinguishes NONE, INIT, FRAME, BEFORE_PAUSE and
BEFORE_RESUME. Preserve marker attributes and source spans alongside the marker;
BEFORE_RESUME and MEMCARD_BOOT. Preserve marker attributes and source spans alongside the marker;
never reconstruct the role from a function name or an import alias. Invalid
attribute targets/combinations MUST be diagnosed rather than silently treated
as ordinary functions. Generic substitution/import processing MUST preserve
canonical source identity and marker metadata. No MemcardBoot marker is defined
by this surface.
canonical source identity and marker metadata. The additional MEMCARD_BOOT marker follows the dedicated memcard contract.
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -283,3 +283,11 @@ MUST preserve bodies and metadata. Common code consumes neutral typed roles,
never PBS ASTs/names. The ordinary assembled entry remains physical FunctionId
zero; hook targets are nonzero after deterministic linking. Common Registry/PBX
validation and production runtime admission remain mandatory defenses.
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -0,0 +1,153 @@
# Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification
Owner: compiler/pbs; propagation to compiler/general and studio.
## Source configuration and identity
`prometeu.json` accepts numeric integral `app_id` (uint32, 0..4294967295) and
optional integral `memcard_slots` (1..64). Strings, booleans, Null, fractions and
out-of-range values MUST fail validation. Memcard opt-in MUST have exactly one
role 3 target, capability memcard and a bootstrap boundary. Memcard imports without
that complete declaration MUST fail before launch; ordinary projects remain unchanged.
Studio persists an explicit initial app_id for new projects and adopts the
legacy generated value once for an older project before shipping. Adoption MUST
preserve unrelated manifest fields and existing explicit IDs. Rename, version,
language and stdlib changes MUST NOT derive a new ID. A copied manifest is the
same game; a distinct game needs an explicitly different identity. The source
identity is propagated losslessly to build/manifest.json, with slots only when
memcard is enabled. Media path and session policy are local host configuration.
## Marker and lifecycle boundary
```pbs
[MemcardBoot]
fn restore(context: long) -> int {
// Inspect admitted RAM and provide presentation through @sdk:mem.
return 0;
}
```
The marker MUST select a nongeneric top-level user function of exact signature
(long)->int with no captures. It accepts no arguments and MUST NOT combine with
another lifecycle marker. Doc metadata, global access and internal closures remain
allowed. Uniqueness is per compiled image and canonical source identity, including
imports and reexports. Names and normal direct calls do not grant lifecycle authority.
The target and its dependencies MUST survive optimization without source callers.
Registry role is 3 and physical FunctionId MUST NOT be zero.
PBS contributes an explicit neutral host-bootstrap request through serializable
common lifecycle declarations. Common assembly emits mem.bootstrap@1 HOSTCALL
with 0 arguments/1 Int32 result after all file/module/project initialization,
inside the once-per-boot guard and before the first Frame. It discards the gate
result after runtime admission. It MUST NOT directly invoke the role, inspect
PBS names or teach the runtime Init/Frame concepts. Ordinary images emit no gate.
READY=0 and INCONSISTENT=1, diagnostic text (at most 1024 UTF-8 bytes), continuation,
budget/trap behavior and provisional registration follow the runtime contract.
A commit submitted in the hook stays pending until READY/coherent registration;
the hook MUST return rather than await it. Resume/remount does not rerun Init or
bootstrap. BeforePause may submit/return and BeforeResume may query across frames.
## MemcardBuffer
`@sdk:mem` exports the nongeneric opaque source type MemcardBuffer. Construct
`new MemcardBuffer(capacity)` with int capacity in 0..4096. Storage is fixed length
and zero initialized; `capacity() -> int`, `read(index: int) -> int` and
`write(index: int, value: int) -> void` provide checked access. Reads always return
an int, with no vacancy/optional representation. Values MUST be in 0..255;
invalid capacity/index/value traps before mutation. Copies alias the same buffer.
The compiler MUST identify the origin-verified SDK declaration, not its spelling,
and lower it directly to concrete Array<Int32> in common Registry/PBX. There is
no Struct wrapper, Dynamic boxing, automatic conversion from ordinary arrays,
copying adapter, new runtime BuiltinId or syscall. Allocation and work obey the
existing VM limits and element charge (four bytes per element). Ordinary PBS
arrays retain their existing vacancy and optional-read semantics.
The same carrier serves slot_read, slot_write and presentation. Successful reads
mutate the same buffer only over the returned range. The buffer owns guest RAM,
not a persistent logical slot or the runtime's asynchronous snapshot.
## Installed SDK
`import {Mem} from @sdk:mem;` selects the forwarding facade. LowMem contains the
exact module mem/version 1/capability memcard host bindings. Bootstrap is compiler
owned; a game MUST NOT manually substitute a direct hook call or bootstrap call.
All numeric domain results/context/request use long, except the Int32 bootstrap
result. Flags are bool; text is str; ranges/local slots are int; presentation
format version is long to represent uint32. Byte transport is MemcardBuffer, each
value 0..255, at most 4096 per transfer; slot capacity is 65536 private bytes.
| Native ID | Binding | Arguments | Results (native order) |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| 0x4200 | bootstrap | 0 | int readiness |
| 0x4201 | slot_count | 1 | status, count |
| 0x4202 | slot_stat | 2 | status, has_payload, used_bytes, generation, update_at, crc32c, dirty |
| 0x4203 | slot_read | 6 | status, bytes_read |
| 0x4204 | slot_write | 6 | status, bytes_written |
| 0x4205 | slot_commit | 2 | status, request |
| 0x4206 | slot_clear | 2 | status |
| 0x4207 | query | 2 | status, state, reason |
| 0x4208 | release | 2 | status |
| 0x4209 | info | 1 | status, mode, is_new, recovered, degraded, write_blocked |
| 0x420A | metadata | 1 | status, title, data_format_version, created_at |
| 0x420B | presentation | 8 | status |
| 0x420C | diagnostic | 2 | status |
| 0x420D | publish_presentation | 1 | status, request |
slot_stat.has_payload is numeric 0/1; dirty/info health flags are bool.
The PBS source tuple groups generation/update_at/crc32c under `stat.durable`;
recursive flattening preserves all seven native results and their exact types/order,
without increasing the language's six-field tuple bound. CRC/generation/timestamp
are durable descriptor data; used_bytes/dirty describe RAM. Unsigned 64-bit values
retain their bit pattern in long. This SDK introduces no general save codec.
The installed facade uses origin-checked exact host forwarding. Its callsites
emit the native operation directly, preserving error Null payloads until the
caller checks status; an intermediate typed-return wrapper MUST NOT turn an
ordinary domain error into a VM type trap. Argument order and evaluation are
preserved. The private HostForward binding accepts only a single exact host
return of unchanged positional parameters and matching result ABI.
Every operation checks status before using payload. Error payload positions are
Null and MUST remain unobserved on a failed status. Status 0 is OK; 3 no space,
4 access denied, 5 corrupt, 6 indeterminate, 7 unavailable, 8 invalid state/canceled,
9 busy, 10 read-only/counter exhausted, 11 invalid range, 12 unsupported,
13 IO error, 16 out of memory. Type/heap/carrier violations are VM traps.
Submitting a commit does not establish persistence. Query state 0 pending,
1 success, 2 failure, 3 indeterminate, 4 memory-only is independent of reason.
Reason 15 is deadline/restart; Success/15 is valid. Only one request/result is
retained until release. Release MUST NOT free in-flight resources. A source slot
is readable but rejects writes/clear with BUSY while committing; other slots
continue. Clear changes RAM and requires explicit commit. No implicit retries,
autosave or disk waits are hidden by the facade.
## Provider boundary and qualification
Runtime owns hosts/headless/storage, explicit persistent/fresh-RAM/load-existing-RAM
choices, concurrent image access, discard confirmation and reconciliation. Studio
uses supported public configuration/operations/diagnostics of its configured
installation. Missing/failed media MUST NOT silently choose memory-only. Image
creation is explicit and never overwrites a file. The development image location
is .studio/memcard.pmc, outside build output; shared images require explicit choice.
Transport loss/timeout/forced termination cannot prove rollback or durable failure.
A missing provider surface is an explicit external dependency, never invented flags,
a second host or a duplicated SO/Hub UI. RAM survives pause/resume.
The installed opt-in `memcard/` subproject demonstrates presentation, status-first
read/write, query and release separately from the ordinary example. Qualification
MUST distinguish source/PBX, native production-host and configured-process evidence.
Complete persistence proof requires SUCCESS, process termination, a new process on
the same image, exact bytes, and the same result after a project-version change.
Record provider revision, OS/architecture, runtime dev/release and PBS optimizer
variants. Native injection is useful contract evidence but never substitutes for
that process proof.
## References
- [Runtime memcard contract](../../../../../runtime/docs/specs/runtime/08-save-memory-and-memcard.md).
- [Common Registry](<../../compiler/25. Typed Registry and PBX v0 Specification.md>).
@@ -80,7 +80,7 @@ Rules:
- Attributes are not first-class values and are not reflectable in v1 core.
- Attributes do not automatically survive into runtime or bytecode artifacts.
- An attribute affects runtime artifacts only when another specification defines an explicit lowering for its semantic effect.
- In v1 core, the normative reserved attributes are `Host`, `Capability`, `AssetLowering`, `BuiltinType`, `BuiltinConst`, `IntrinsicCall`, `Init`, `Frame`, `BeforePause`, `BeforeResume`, `InitAllowed`, and `Doc`.
- In v1 core, the normative reserved attributes are `Host`, `Capability`, `AssetLowering`, `BuiltinType`, `BuiltinConst`, `IntrinsicCall`, `Init`, `Frame`, `BeforePause`, `BeforeResume`, `MemcardBoot`, `InitAllowed`, and `Doc`.
- `Host` is valid only on a host method signature declared directly inside a reserved stdlib/interface-module `declare host` body.
- `Capability` is valid only on a host method signature declared directly inside a reserved stdlib/interface-module `declare host` body.
- `AssetLowering` is valid only on a host method signature declared directly inside a reserved stdlib/interface-module `declare host` body.
@@ -858,3 +858,11 @@ Direct calls remain normal calls and do not request an OS transition or create
a controlled invocation. Runtime FunctionId zero is reserved for the ordinary
entry; physical hook IDs are validated after linking. Init/Frame requirements
and their frontend/common assembly remain unchanged.
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -570,3 +570,11 @@ See [PBS generic contracts](16.%20Generic%20Contracts%20Specification.md).
Generic struct/function barrels export declarations and ordered parameters, including complete function signatures, rather than enumerated specializations. Imports and aliases preserve nominal origins and definition-scoped bodies/private helpers. Specializations are shared across equivalent uses and do not export private dependencies. SDK and program sources use the same language machinery.
See [Concrete generic structs and free functions](17.%20Generic%20Structs%20and%20Free%20Functions%20Specification.md).
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -252,3 +252,11 @@ The current temporary contract is:
6. PBX `SYSC` declares required host bindings, not authority.
7. Loader validation fails if PBX host requirements exceed granted cartridge capabilities.
8. `manifest.json` is not entrypoint authority for PBS v1 boot.
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -411,4 +411,12 @@ effects. Fatal traps/host failures and unfinished fuel exhaustion fail the
session, block gameplay and retain the existing crash envelope, without retry,
rollback or compensation. HALT is OS termination, not successful hook return.
Existing capability/service rules apply, without auto-save, flush, disk wait,
transition veto or reason argument. MemcardBoot and persistence are separate.
transition veto or reason argument. MemcardBoot and persistence follow the dedicated memcard chapter.
## Memcard integration
The [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK contract](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>)
defines the additional [MemcardBoot] marker, exact signature, neutral once-only
bootstrap, project identity/slot validation and complete installed mem ABI.
Its requirements apply in addition to this chapter; pause/resume remain independent.
@@ -202,3 +202,5 @@ IDs returned by project context. The alias catalog is generated by the frontend
build from this single source directory. It does not read a second spec tree.
The internal resource path is `pbs-knowledge/specs/<numbered filename>.md`;
reference clients resolve IDs through the catalog instead of constructing paths.
- [Memcard Bootstrap and SDK](<26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>): opt-in persistence producer and runtime-consumer boundaries.
@@ -113,8 +113,8 @@ requires relocating every PUSH_CONST index; changing only the table is invalid.
Roles are None 0, BeforePause 1, BeforeResume 2 and MemcardBoot 3. Nonzero roles
are unique, cannot target entry zero and cannot capture. Pause/resume have empty
signatures; MemcardBoot has `(Int64) -> Int32`. This metadata does not implement
frontend hook selection, mem.bootstrap gating or persistence.
signatures; MemcardBoot has `(Int64) -> Int32`. Frontend-owned role selection and neutral common bootstrap assembly implement
the producer boundary; runtime owns persistence and admission.
Implementations are unique per Struct/Trait pair, complete and ordered. Each
method target has an exact signature with a concrete Struct receiver first,
@@ -286,4 +286,24 @@ Common emission validates unique nonzero roles, empty pause/resume signatures
and capture lists, and final hook FunctionIds other than zero. The ordinary
entry and synthetic Init/Frame assembly keep role None. Calling a hook as an
ordinary function does not request an OS transition. PBS marker syntax belongs
to its frontend; MemcardBoot selection/bootstrap is a separate producer scope.
to its frontend. MemcardBoot uses a typed role and an explicit neutral bootstrap
request, specified below.
## Neutral host bootstrap requests
IRLifecycleFileDeclaration and IRLifecycleDeclaration carry ordered serializable
bootstrapCalls, each ordinary HostCallMetadata (module/name/version/argSlots/retSlots).
Empty requests preserve the existing lifecycle. Aggregation preserves requests
and deduplicates identical boundaries from repeated file contributions. Frontends
MUST request a zero-argument boundary explicitly; the assembler MUST NOT inspect
language syntax/names. It emits CALL_HOST and discards each result after ordered
module/project initialization, before setting the boot guard and invoking Frame.
Requests that require operands from initializer stacks MUST fail validation.
The memcard producer requests mem.bootstrap@1, 0→1. Its role 3 target and callees
are external-entry retention roots. Production project validation requires coherent
slots 1..64, capability memcard, unique role 3 and the boundary before launch.
This is distinct from a direct CALL to the hook. Host storage and headless transport
remain runtime-owned and absent from the common IR. See the PBS
[producer contract](<../compiler-languages/pbs/26. Memcard Bootstrap and SDK Specification.md>).
@@ -234,6 +234,16 @@ Reset leaves the runtime unbooted and clears its capture. It does not implicitly
boot the cartridge again. A subsequent explicit boot may reuse the session's
known build cartridge; an invalidated process requires an explicit new session.
Memcard use negotiates the provider's protocol 1.1 extension explicitly. The
adapter projects mount/choice/state/reconcile/RAM-continuation and protected
teardown as specified in [Project-local memcard integration](<8. Project-Local Studio State Specification.md#published-memcard-host-integration>).
Native `memcard_error` refusal preserves structured state and the live channel;
it does not trigger process termination or detach. `action_required` preserves
known progress and becomes `ACTION_REQUIRED`, with the resident session retained.
Human reclaim never supplies discard consent. Following a protected cleanup
refusal, DEV offers a separate confirmed discard/retry action; canceling it
preserves the process and control guard.
| Configurable, handshake-advertised limit | Default |
| --- | --- |
| Frames per advance | 600 |
@@ -183,15 +183,20 @@ Input objects reject undeclared fields. IDs are nonempty opaque strings.
| `studio_control_release` | task | none | state=MANUAL, only after ordered cleanup |
| `studio_language_query` | task | operation, parameters | Supported LSP query/proposal result |
| `studio_build_start` | task | clientRequestId | operationId, clientRequestId, state |
| `studio_headless_boot` | task | buildId | sessionId, buildId; boot uses the task's known build |
| `studio_headless_reset` | task | none | Current session/reset state |
| `studio_headless_boot` | task | buildId, optional memcard/memcardChoice | sessionId, buildId; boot uses the task's known build |
| `studio_headless_reset` | task | optional discardUnsaved/pendingWrites | Current session/reset state and negotiated memcard state |
| `studio_headless_set_input` | task | input | Current session acknowledgement |
| `studio_headless_clear_input` | task | none | Current session acknowledgement |
| `studio_headless_advance` | task | clientRequestId, frames | operationId, clientRequestId, state |
| `studio_headless_capture` | task | none | Canonical image and metadata in section 6 |
| `studio_headless_state` | task | none | Current session and runtime state |
| `studio_headless_fault` | task | none | fault object or null, preserving structural fault details |
| `studio_headless_shutdown` | task | none | Session shutdown acknowledgement after managed cleanup |
| `studio_headless_shutdown` | task | optional discardUnsaved/pendingWrites | Session shutdown acknowledgement/final memcard state after managed cleanup; native refusal preserves session |
| `studio_headless_memcard_state` | task | none | Native media/session/dirty/request/IO/recovery state |
| `studio_headless_memcard_mount` | task | action, access, optional path | Explicit idle open/create through the provider |
| `studio_headless_memcard_unmount` | task | none | Explicit idle media release |
| `studio_headless_memcard_reconcile` | task | none | Runtime-owned same-card revalidation while suspended |
| `studio_headless_memcard_continue_in_memory` | task | none | Explicit runtime-owned RAM continuation while suspended |
| `studio_operation_get` | task | exactly one of operationId/clientRequestId | State, known progress, typed result/failure |
| `studio_operation_cancel` | task | operationId | operationId, cancellationRequested |
@@ -401,6 +406,17 @@ that process, invalidates previous buildIds and requires a fresh explicit boot.
Synchronous headless failures finish their worker before returning the error,
so a corrective call cannot race the failed worker's admission lock.
Memcard boot options are local host configuration, never an arbitrary cartridge
path. `memcard` contains explicit action/access and optional image path;
`memcardChoice` is an explicit provider choice. Protocol 1.1 plus capability
`memcard` is required before mutation. `MEMCARD_ERROR` preserves native
operation/reason/state in `runtimeError`. Refused reset/shutdown keep the attached
session and task available for inspection and a later explicit choice.
`discardUnsaved` and `pendingWrites` are forwarded only when supplied. Neither
ordinary Stop/task release nor connection loss supplies discard consent.
See [published memcard host integration](<8. Project-Local Studio State Specification.md#published-memcard-host-integration>)
for local paths, protected human reclaim and `ACTION_REQUIRED` outcomes.
Task-local operation/build records are discarded after worker termination on
return, revocation or project closure. Cleanup failures never restore authority;
the records are still discarded after managed work stops. Neither connection
@@ -536,7 +552,8 @@ authentication, Origin, endpoint/method/version handling, tool dispatch, malform
or oversized input, closure, restart and old-token rejection. Provider doubles
exist only in tests. Composition starts/closes transport with Studio.
The production registry composes all 17 tools as of step 23, including headless
The production registry composes 22 tools, including five negotiated memcard
controls and the original headless
handlers bound to the actual `HeadlessProcessGateway`. Missing project runtime
configuration fails at boot with `RUNTIME_UNAVAILABLE`; tool discovery does not
grant authority or launch a process. No fake runtime is shipped.
@@ -138,3 +138,73 @@ commit. Failure aborts credentials/files and reports a failed grant. Revoke/clos
invalidate credentials before asynchronous work cleanup, then remove owned
publication and release ownership. File cleanup failure MUST NOT prevent runtime
cancellation. An already-admitted release response MUST remain deliverable.
## Cartridge identity and local memcard configuration
Versioned prometeu.json owns explicit numeric uint32 app_id and optional integral
memcard_slots in 1..64. Studio project references preserve both. New projects persist
their initial identity. Before shipping a legacy project, the current legacy
name/version/language/stdlib hash is adopted once via atomic manifest replacement,
with unknown fields preserved. Existing explicit IDs are authoritative and are
never regenerated on upgrades/rename/clone. A copied manifest represents the same
game; a distinct game requires an explicitly different identity. Invalid values
MUST fail rather than fall back to hashing. build/manifest.json propagates ID and
coherent slots/capability. Compiler validation additionally requires MemcardBoot
and the bootstrap boundary for memcard images.
Media path and session choice are local runtime-host configuration. The development
image location is `.studio/memcard.pmc`, outside rebuildable output; shared external
images require explicit selection. Studio creates no media implicitly and never
replaces existing saves. Runtime owns creation/mounting/concurrency, headless,
player-choice/dirty-discard workflow and reconciliation. Studio consumes only a
published interface of its configured runtime installation. It MUST NOT invent
flags/JSONL fields, implement an alternative host or duplicate SO/Hub.
Missing provider controls/dirty-pending diagnostics remain explicit integration
dependencies. They do not alter the guest ABI or permit silent memory-only fallback.
A process failure does not establish whether publication occurred; supervision
errors MUST NOT be presented as durable save failure/rollback. Native host evidence
and configured-process reopen evidence MUST be reported separately.
### Published memcard host integration
Memcard projects MUST negotiate protocol 1.1 and capability `memcard` with their
configured installation before mounting media or booting. Ordinary projects keep
the 1.0 flow. Runtime version strings are not capability detection.
`studio_headless_boot` accepts optional `memcard` mount configuration (`path`,
explicit `action:open/create`, explicit `access:read_write/read_only`) and the
explicit `memcardChoice:persistent/memory_fresh/memory_existing`. Studio sends
the published `memcard_mount` before `boot`, preserving native domain failures.
Omitted mount path selects the project-local development path; it does not imply
mounting, creation or a memory choice. An explicit create at that default path
may create its `.studio` parent; the runtime alone formats and creates the media.
Explicit external paths resolve against the project root. No open failure may
be retried as create, repaired or converted into a RAM choice automatically.
Local `.studio/setup.json` MAY set `memcardPath` to explicitly select another
image; relative selections resolve against the project root. Desktop Debug passes
the published `--memcard` option for opt-in projects, and headless mount defaults
to that same selection. An explicit per-session mount path overrides it for that
session. No desktop `--create-memcard` is inferred from file absence or launch.
Ordinary projects receive no media startup options. The default development
selection remains `.studio/memcard.pmc` when `memcardPath` is absent.
The consumer exposes native state, idle mount/unmount, same-card reconciliation
and explicit continuation in memory. These operations preserve the runtime's
state and choices; they do not expose private payloads. Reset/shutdown accept
explicit `discardUnsaved` and `pendingWrites:wait/cancel`; omission preserves
provider defaults. A native refusal MUST retain the process, channel and session
association. A subsequent explicit decision can retry. The structured
`memcard_error` is carried as `MEMCARD_ERROR` with unchanged native details.
An `action_required` advance is an `ACTION_REQUIRED` outcome with native
diagnostics, preserving known completed frames and the resident session.
Human reclaim first attempts protected shutdown without discard consent. On
refusal it keeps manual mutation locked and exposes the diagnostics. DEV offers
a separately confirmed discard of unsaved game RAM and cancellation of admitted
writes before retrying cleanup. Canceling that confirmation sends no consent.
Neither task release, Stop, reclaim nor a timeout implicitly permits discard.
Forced termination remains infrastructure failure with unknown publication
outcome; it MUST NOT manufacture a durable save result.